Pakistan's Bin Laden Report

Marauder06

Intel Enabler
Verified SOF
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
Messages
11,201
Location
CONUS
Finally, something about the Bin Laden raid that wasn't written by a SEAL or leaked by our own government:

ISLAMABAD, Pakistan – The leak of a 336-page report investigating the security lapses that led to both Osama bin Laden’s extensive stay in Pakistan and the raid that killed him on May 1, 2011 shows that Pakistan has finally started asking itself some tough questions.

The Abbottabad Commission, whose report was first obtained by Al Jazeera, was launched two years ago. The report is the most comprehensive Pakistani account to date of what went wrong in the Islamic Republic’s hunt for the world’s most wanted man.

What went wrong? It's the Americans' fault, of course!
The frankness of the report is unprecedented for an official study commissioned by the nuclear powered Islamic republic that often blames foreign powers for all that ails its economy and its people.

Hm, well, that's different...

The report details bin Laden’s movements around Pakistan for almost a decade (from a major city, to a mountain resort, to small town, to a cantonment); the municipal permission to build an illegal structure that eventually became the mansion where he lived and fathered two children; the inability to follow up on intelligence shared by the United States; the lax attitude and negligence displayed by the Pakistanis that allowed the U.S. to conduct both the ground surveillance and the Navy SEAL raid that embarrassed the country; and even the inability of a policeman who once stopped bin Laden for speeding to recognize him.

The details paint the picture of one of the worst intelligence failures in history.

Ah yes, there it is, the "intel failure." How the hell is this an intel failure? Pakistan's intel service, the ISI, was utterly complicit in shielding Bin Laden. The CIA knew and said publicly for over a decade that Bin Laden was in Pakistan. According to public reports, they knew for months that he was in Abbotabad before the SEALs went and got him. This isn't an intel failure, it is a failure of national policy on both the US and Pakistani sides.
 
Last edited:

AWP

Formerly Known as Freefalling
SOF Support
Joined
Sep 8, 2006
Messages
16,435
Location
Not Afghanistan
To a certain extent, the ISI IS the the pakistani gov't. Nice face-saving gesture by the Nickelback of Asia, though I believe it to be as sincere as "Of course your ass doesn't look fat in those jeans."

I think my criticism of US foreign relations/ policy with Pakistan is well known on this board, to say nothing of my thoughts on that wretched little country. In an effort to clean up my vitriol, I'd like to offer:

Fornicate with thyself, Pakistan, preferrably with a rotary instrument used in the serving of pizza.
 

Scotth

Verified Military
Joined
Nov 8, 2007
Messages
1,496
Location
Minneapolis, MN
It's just illustrates that Pakistan's political system has some similarities to the US political system. In both countries the politician happily point the finger of blame at "intel failures" whenever they're playing the game of covering thy own @ss from any responsibility.
 
Last edited:
Top