Uniform's and uniformity as a rule is designed as a tool to INSTILL discipline in Soldiers. Disciplined Soldiers (READ: "Warriors") don't need it to RETAIN discipline to be a good Soldier, that's what they are by instinct and that why they do what they do. They are there to BE a professional Soldier first and not just use the military as an ends to a means for the financial and educational benefits. Yes, they still take advantage of said benefits, as they should but, they could have done far less in the Army and received the same benefits. They have chosen the more challenging, difficult and rewarding path of the true professional Soldier.
The BCT/OSUT/AIT environment and units that have no prerequisite of a "higher standard" for membership need this tool to instill and dually maintain discipline, no question.
Units that foster a "perform or leave" type of discipline do not need this rudimentary form of discipline.
The Army needs to quit looking at all Soldiers as being equal because quite frankly they're simply not.
There are unit's that by their very nature have better Soldiers than others. It's just a fact, sorry, someone has to be better, no different than even though you're in the major leagues of baseball... You may be a Tampa Bay Devil Ray and not a Yankee (one example...)
The powers-to-be just need to accept it (Get over it) and move on and treat people accordingly. When considering the training and the dedication a Soldier must have to rate the title and belong to a unit of Special Forces, The Ranger Regiment and even LRS, SOAR, the 82nd ABN (No particular order...) and so forth, they just foster a Soldier that is more disciplined, thus superior, than that of a Soldier somewhere in the rear echelon of the NBIG GREEN ARMY.
Look at the facts cumulatively such as average GT scores, PT scores, military education, lack of UCMJ actions and etc and etc...
When a Soldier says "Why can't I dress like that guy" the answer should be "Because you don't need to and he does, It's not a fucking fashion show! What a Soldier should wares should be whatever is most befitting the accomplishment of his (or her) job... PERIOD. A basic issue uniform can cover most of this especially in a day-to-day garrison environment for most Soldiers. In a field environment (Training or combat) that is an entirely different scenario. If a "regular Soldier" sees a "snake eater type" training or somewhere down range and says "Why can't I wear a pair of Merrells, a ball cap,plate hangers and un blouse my boots?" the answer should be "Why don't you go and try and do that guys job for a month... Hell, go on one road march, one exercise, one mission with the likes of him and his peers and then answer your own question?"
It's not just a matter of WANT (It is on some levels but, so what, some have earned a little freedom of as to how they dress), it's a matter of NEED.
The Army has to fill all kinds of jobs from the most rear echelon, non-deployable support jobs all the way to a professional warrior specialized in the art of guerilla warfare. I just don't see how you can treat these two extremely different types of soldiers the exact same, they're to large a dichotomy, a total contrast.
The only reason it's been done for so long is that the professional warrior is DISIPLINED and does what he's told, (for the most part ;)) no matter how ridicules it seams that he "look" just like the rest of the Army despite his tactical needs to which brings my long winded diatribe here full circle and back to my original point. Some Soldiers don't need such elementary things to maintain their disciplined and professional posture and some flatly do...
(This also adds to why so many were so upset when they GAVE AWAY the black beret of the 75th RR to the rest of the regular Army.)
An elite Soldier gets no extra pay (Recruiter pro-pay is more than freaking jump-pay!) so they do not strive for success in tangible way I/E $$$$$$$. (An E-6 on an SF team makes as much as an E-6 anywhere else in the big green Army...) The "Professional Soldier" may get their own personal reward for DOING MORE from intangibles such as being able to simply wear the elite mark of destination of a simple uniform difference. It may be a different colored headgear, a badge, a tab, a pair of jump boots or simply being able to grow a beard when down range and wear a sleeveless T-shirt. It's basic human nature that no one is uninfluenced by. (If you say "not me" you're full of shit... ;)) It seems like a small price to pay to have these types amongst our military, I think that if someone out there in the big green "regular" Army's one goal in life is to dress like an SF Soldier... THEN FUCKING GO SF!
I'll be shutting up now...
RANT OFF.