Why Study War?

AMRUSMCR

Only 92% Evil
Verified Military
Joined
Sep 6, 2006
Messages
204
Location
Midwest
This is a long, but good read. I'm only going to post the intro and final paragraphs. If you go to the website for the full text, at the end there are some excellent reading recommendations for those that enjoy Military History.

Full Body of the Article

Article Intro:

August 21, 2007
Why Study War?
Military history teaches us about honor, sacrifice, and the inevitability of conflict.
by Victor Davis Hanson
City Journal (Summer 2007)

Try explaining to a college student that Tet was an American military victory. You’ll provoke not a counterargument — let alone an assent — but a blank stare: Who or what was Tet? Doing interviews about the recent hit movie 300, I encountered similar bewilderment from listeners and hosts. Not only did most of them not know who the 300 were or what Thermopylae was; they seemed clueless about the Persian Wars altogether.

It’s no surprise that civilian Americans tend to lack a basic understanding of military matters. Even when I was a graduate student, 30-some years ago, military history — understood broadly as the investigation of why one side wins and another loses a war, and encompassing reflections on magisterial or foolish generalship, technological stagnation or breakthrough, and the roles of discipline, bravery, national will, and culture in determining a conflict’s outcome and its consequences — had already become unfashionable on campus. Today, universities are even less receptive to the subject.

Article End:


Finally, military history has the moral purpose of educating us about past sacrifices that have secured our present freedom and security. If we know nothing of Shiloh, Belleau Wood, Tarawa, and Chosun, the crosses in our military cemeteries are just pleasant white stones on lush green lawns. They no longer serve as reminders that thousands endured pain and hardship for our right to listen to what we wish on our iPods and to shop at Wal-Mart in safety — or that they expected future generations, links in this great chain of obligation, to do the same for those not yet born. The United States was born through war, reunited by war, and saved from destruction by war. No future generation, however comfortable and affluent, should escape that terrible knowledge.

What, then, can we do to restore the study of war to its proper place in the life of the American mind? The challenge isn’t just to reform the graduate schools or the professoriate, though that would help. On a deeper level, we need to reexamine the larger forces that have devalued the very idea of military history — of war itself. We must abandon the naive faith that with enough money, education, or good intentions we can change the nature of mankind so that conflict, as if by fiat, becomes a thing of the past. In the end, the study of war reminds us that we will never be gods. We will always just be men, it tells us. Some men will always prefer war to peace; and other men, we who have learned from the past, have a moral obligation to stop them.
 

Gypsy

SSSO 1&2/Plank Owner
Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2006
Messages
3,641
Location
Red dot in a blue state
Thanks A, think I'll pour another cup of java while I read this...looks very interesting. I like much of what the author has written over time.
 

AMRUSMCR

Only 92% Evil
Verified Military
Joined
Sep 6, 2006
Messages
204
Location
Midwest
Thanks Gypsy. It's the first time I've been introduced to his essays so I will hit up his archives on his site to see the rest.
 

AWP

Formerly Known as Freefalling
SOF Support
Joined
Sep 8, 2006
Messages
16,436
Location
Not Afghanistan
VDH is dry and I don't agree with some of his conclusions. I think he should stick to classic history and less modern stuff. :2c:
 
Top