- Joined
- Sep 12, 2012
- Messages
- 12,835
That's a very misleading article title. They are not asking for a blanket search history. They are asking for a search of a specific term, between specific dates. I can see where this could turn into a slippery slope, but I personally don't have a problem with that warrant. It's like an Internet version of an APB for a specific car. If you're driving that make/model/color, you're probably going to get stopped and questioned to see if you are who they are after.
I'm having a difficult time agreeing with your thought process, especially the bolded. I think it is very different then being pulled over because I was driving a newer model black 4-Runner, similar to whomever "they" are looking for is driving. Say for example I am writing a book about a kinky sex murder and the scenarios I have been extensively researching on Google (and watching videos of) are strikingly similar to something that happens locally. Local PD get a warrant with specifics about the murder and my name pops up?
- Now I have to explain to them that I'm just writing a book and that it is a coincidence that my book is very similar to what just happened for real ?
- Now I am forced to come up with some type of alibi the time of the murder ? What if I don't have one, now I am a suspect???
- At a minimum I am going to feel the need to hire an attorney.
Seeking the browsing history for a specific person is one thing, but reversing that and doing a broad search of specific terms in the hopes of finding a suspect? That is something else all together.
I've been reading the links @Board and Seize posted on page one of this thread and am slowing changing my thinking on the whole privacy issue.
Police got search warrant for everyone who Googled Edina resident's name
According to the warrant application, Lindman said he had reason to believe the suspect used Google to find a picture of the person they believed to be the account holder.
Larson signed off on the search warrant on Feb. 1. According to court documents, Lindman served it about 20 minutes later.
McGeveran said it’s unusual for a judge to sign off on a warrant that bases probable cause on such few facts.
“It’s much more usual for a search warrant to be used to gather evidence for a suspect that’s already identified, instead of using evidence to find a suspect,” he said. “If the standards for getting a broad warrant like this are not strong, you can have a lot of police fishing expeditions.”