Case Study: Tabs and Tyrants

1) Net good, and no unit I was in prohibited them.

2) During my commo days, the convention for gaining a nickname was fairly nebulous. My ex got his nickname by knocking on his buddy’s barracks door, looking for a spare connector. When Cornflake (our SA armorer/chem NCO) answered the door, he bellowed “it’s Daisy!” That was on a Saturday morning. By work call Monday, half the battalion was calling him Daisy. It stuck until he got out five years later.

3) I had two, from two separate social circles. One was Gizmo, earned because of the impression I used to do of a mogwai getting a blowjob. The other was DC. It stood for “Dancing Clown,” based on a drunken dance party. The guy that gave me the full nick didn’t think I’d embrace it, and my friends shortened it to DC when it became obvious that yeah, I’m well aware that I can’t dance.

*Edit for spelling
 
“Dammit, Pigpen, you can’t do anything right.”

That is pretty much all Faith seemed to hear anytime he was around 2nd Platoon. And, he had to admit, it was a pretty accurate statement. With SGT Wilson off at Ranger School, Private Thigpen (Faith decided to call him by his real name) was a hot mess. No other NCO was willing to take Thigpen under his wing, and without “close adult supervision,” Thigpen was struggling. He gained weight, his room standards slipped, his uniform was disheveled, and he never seemed to be on time for anything. The latter, in particular, earned the ire of his platoon mates because of the policy of mass platoon-wide punishment for individual tardiness.

As he walked past 2nd Platoon getting smoked yet again for something else that Private Thigpen screwed up, Faith heard one of his platoon mates hiss “Pigpen, you suck.” Faith felt bad for Private Thigpen, but he had other things to worry about. And besides, he kind of deserved it. He really was an idiot.

A week or so after Sergeant Wilson departed for Ranger School, Delta Company’s first sergeant announced that it was time for 5th Platoon to turn in weapons systems for maintenance. As a heavy weapons platoon, Delta Company’s platoons were outfitted with the tube launched, optically tracked, wire guided missile system (TOW), which was essentially the only anti-armor weapon system in the entire battalion. Each Delta platoon also maintained a pair of .50 caliber machine guns and two Mark 19 automatic grenade launcher, in addition to the standard loadout of small arms.

The TOW missile system has four major components: the launcher, the tripod, the sight, and the missile guidance system. While it is ostensibly “man-portable,” the components are heavy and awkward to carry. That is why the platoons in Delta Company were equipped with a large number of vehicles. Specifically, the platoon had a command vehicle for the platoon leader, a cargo vehicle for the platoon sergeant, and eight “gun trucks” to carry to weapons systems. Although the TOW was allegedly the primary weapon system for the platoon, Delta Company seldom (as in, never) trained against an armored OPFOR. It was always a light infantry fight. So the TOWs tended to stay in the arms room when the unit went to the field, and the turrets of the gun trucks mounted either the .50s or the squad automatic weapon (SAW). While the TOW was considered useless in training, especially in MILES, the Army’s version of Laser Tag, it boasted an exceptional thermal night sight, which most platoons typically jury-rigged to their .50s or Mark 19s to give them an edge at night.

TOW missile components also tend to wear out often. Fortunately, Sergeant Ellery had a time-honored SOP for turning in old TOW parts. Unfortunately for the platoon, that process involved some pretty strenuous physical training. When the platoon assembled for PT formation the morning after the First Sergeant announced turn-in, Faith and the rest of the platoon arrived to find that Sergeant Ellery and the other NCOs in the platoon had come in early and laid out four complete sets of TOW systems which needed to be turned in. No big deal, they could just toss them in the trucks and drive them over.

Nope. The platoon was going to carry them to the turn-in point. OK fine, it’s not that far away, right?

Nope. The turn-in point was eight miles away. They were “ruck-running” to the turn in point… and then formation run back. Round trip: 16 miles. But at least they wouldn’t have to carry the TOWs back with them on the return trip.

“OK, here’s how this works,” announced Sergeant Ellery. “Two equal teams, two TOW systems each. The PL has First and Second squad. Third and Fourth squads are with me.”

“OK,” Faith thought, “those are pretty equal teams. We have a shot at this.” He and the members of First and Second squads began to shoulder the equipment.

“Which one of these sucks the most to carry?” Faith asked of his team.

“The MGS,” was the unanimous response. Faith grabbed one of the missile guidance systems. It was basically a big, think square metal box with a long canvas strap to make it easier to carry. “Easier” was relative, of course. The box was deceptively heavy and extraordinarily awkward to carry. Especially in a hurry. “Man portable, my ass,” Faith thought as he shouldered the strap.

Faith paid close attention as Ellery explained the rules. “As fast as you can to the turn in point. One person each to carry the launcher, the tripod, the MGS, and the cables. Two ways to win: first team to get all of their systems across is the team winner. First group of five from either team to get an entire TOW system set up outside the turn-in yard is the crew winner. No inhibiting anyone on the other team. You must travel by foot, under your own power. No shortcuts, straight down the main road. After turn in, formation run back. Any questions?”

One of the specialists in Third Squad raised his hand.

“Yes, Hickman?” Ellery asked.

“What do we win, sergeant?”

“Bragging rights?” Ellery suggested.

“Laaaaaame!” Hickman jokingly responded.

Ellery reconsidered. “Ok check it out. The team that wins gets their vehicles PMCS’d by the losing team next Motor Pool Monday. Well, that was certainly an incentive. Doing preventive maintenance checks and services (PMCS) on your own vehicle was bad enough. But having to do it for someone else’s truck? Well that just wouldn’t stand.

“And for the first crew to get a complete TOW system set up, get’s a three-day pass. This Friday. I already cleared it with First Sergeant.” This announcement was EXTREMELY motivating. There are few things Soldiers like more than having time off. Faith’s girlfriend was coming up from her college in Georgia this weekend. There was going to be nothing stopping him from being on that winning crew.

“OK, come up with your team plan,” Ellery told the platoon. “There are three stops: when you get to CIF (the post’s central issue facility for equipment), you stop and do 101 pushups. When you get to the Division headquarters, 101 situps. When you get to the front gate of the turn-in facility, 125 flutter kicks.” That last number confused Faith. They were in the 101st Airborne Division so it made sense to do the 101 pushups and 101 situps. But the 125 flutter kicks seemed a bit arbitrary. His confusion must have shown on his face.

“Because we’re the 327th Infantry Regiment!” Ellery exclaimed excitedly. OK now it makes sense. 101 pushups plus 101 situps plus 125 flutter kicks equals 327. Maybe. It’s too early for math…

“Well, we’re in 1st Battalion so maybe we could just do 1 / 1 / 1 instead of 101 / 101 / 125…” a Soldier helpfully suggested.

“Shut up Hickman, before Sarge makes you do a hundred pushups before you even leave,” growled one of the platoon’s NCOs.

“That’s actually a good idea,” said Sergeant Ellery, a sadistic gleam in his eye. “Platoon—atten…tion! Half right, FACE! Front lean and rest, MOVE! In cadence…”

Well that sucked. Most of the platoon was capable of doing 100 pushups consecutively, but doing them in slow cadence was always a smoker.

-----
discussion questions:
1) Have you ever done MOS-related PT like what’s described in the vignette above?
2) What’s the most interesting, useful, and/or fun PT you’ve ever done in a unit? (“Zonk” PT doesn’t count 😉 )
3) With Wilson gone, it looks like Private Thigpen is sliding back into his bad ways. What, if anything, can be done about it?
 
1) hell, yes.... as an 11 and as and 18 and as a91(now 68) and as a 54 (NBC/CBRN)
2)movement to orp, build camp, break camp, movement to obj, e&e/land nav to range, run full weapons drill including range cards, PT Test, then range qual, movement back to Co area. Movements with normal Team Load. 48 hour course.
3) Chapter Thigpen, failure to adapt, General Discharge. Safest for him and for his fellow soldiers. He's coming up on a Barracks/Blanket party if this isn't done fast.
 
“One last thing,” Ellery added as the platoon approached the starting line. “Whatever piece of the TOW you’re starting with, you have to maintain contact with it the entire run.”

A number of men in the platoon groaned, as their assigned pieces were heavy. During PT sessions at his Officer Basic Course, Faith and the other men in his class would rotate the heavy items, such as the Stinger missiles or the mortar base plates, between individuals so that no one person would get exhausted. But that would not be an option this time.

He wasn’t even a full mile into the run before Faith realized that choosing to carry the missile guidance system was a huge mistake. While it was “man-portable,” it wasn’t really designed to be carried over long distances, and definitely wasn’t intended for someone to run with it. It banged painfully against his hip, and was too bulky to be carried on a shoulder or in front of his body. He would just have to manage as best he could.

As they were unencumbered by the weight and bulk of the other pieces of equipment, the men carrying the cables soon outdistanced the others. The men carrying the other pieces, especially the four toting the MGSs, began to lag. Faith was in good shape, but he simply had never trained for something like this. He slowed from a trot, to an “Airborne shuffle,” to basically a quick walk. He was very grateful when he got to the first directed stop, the Central Issue Facility, to do the 101 pushups. Sergeant Ellery was one of the first to arrive at CIF, and held the platoon until everyone arrived. After everyone had gathered, Ellery led the platoon in 101 four-count pushups, effectively doubling the number of pushups completed to 202. No one, not even Ellery, could do that many pushups at one time, especially given the preceding physical activity. As the pushups continued, more and more men dropped from the “front lean and rest” to their knees in order to be able to continue. By the end, everyone was thoroughly smoked.

“OK, five minutes and then you’re released to the next stop, the Division HQ,” Ellery announced.

At this rate, Faith was never going to be able to finish the race… or at least he wasn’t going to finish in any type of appreciable pace. He had to come up with a better solution.

“Remember the rules,” said Ellery as the five-minute break wound down. You have to stay in contact with the piece of equipment you started with, for the duration of the race. Foot movement only. No shortcuts. No cheating. No inhibiting other teams. Next stop is Division HQ. One minute.”

As the members of his four-person team stood up to prepare to continue movement, Faith called out to them.

“Guys, we need a plan if we’re going to win this thing,” he said. The other members of his team nodded in approval.



-----
Given the rules put in place, what would your plan be to move the team’s equipment the rest of the way to the finish line in the fastest way possible?
 
I'm not sure if this plan is either A) feasible or B) realistic, specifically because if the guys aren't around the same height, or the cables are too long, this carry will be ackward and create more work.

However, if they're about the same height, and the cables are about the right length, it may work to:

1. Take one or multiple set of cables. Take one MGS case.
2. Fold cables in half to shorten the length.
3. Run the cable through the MGS case canvas strap.
4. Put a guy on the front end of the cable and the other guy at the back.
5. Run holding the cable on their shoulders, creating tension, with the MGS case suspended in the middle of the cable.

Reevaluate at Division and if it's hilly, and the case slides, consider moving to:

1. One guy carrying cables switching off with a guy carrying the MGS case with each maintaining contact with their original equipment by using a hand as they ran next to each other.

or

2. If the MGS box is big enough, two people carrying the MGS case without using the strap, and putting the cables across their shoulders, while running in step.

This case study is so great to read. It's the highlight of my night.
 
Team carry Items - as long as the original portager has contact with the item, someone else can carry the item - so switch back and forth from the original carrier to one or more platoon members. So a strap attached to the item to allow the original carrier would keep whoever is actually carrying from getting tangled up.
 
I'm not sure if this plan is either A) feasible or B) realistic, specifically because if the guys aren't around the same height, or the cables are too long, this carry will be ackward and create more work.

However, if they're about the same height, and the cables are about the right length, it may work to:

1. Take one or multiple set of cables. Take one MGS case.
2. Fold cables in half to shorten the length.
3. Run the cable through the MGS case canvas strap.
4. Put a guy on the front end of the cable and the other guy at the back.
5. Run holding the cable on their shoulders, creating tension, with the MGS case suspended in the middle of the cable.

Reevaluate at Division and if it's hilly, and the case slides, consider moving to:

1. One guy carrying cables switching off with a guy carrying the MGS case with each maintaining contact with their original equipment by using a hand as they ran next to each other.

or

2. If the MGS box is big enough, two people carrying the MGS case without using the strap, and putting the cables across their shoulders, while running in step.

This case study is so great to read. It's the highlight of my night.

Ref. the bolded part above:

That is actually a really good point, and I think you're probably 100% correct. Thinking back, that might be why we never tried to do it that way in real life. When I do the edits on this, I might delete that part completely, or at least change it up a bit. For purposes of this story, though, it was a brilliant idea and worked perfectly. ;)
 
As a group, Faith’s team of four quickly developed a plan that made it easier to transport the TOW equipment and adhered to the spirit of the rules of the race. The two men carrying the TOW launch tube and tripod lined up one behind the other and put an end of the launcher and tripod on each shoulder. Faith and the soldier on his team carrying the cables ran two of the cables through loops on the MGS and, holding one end in each hand, were able to share the load between the two of them. After about the second mile, most individuals went from a slow run to spurts of running interspersed with periods of walking.

By the third mile, there was little running. By the fourth mile, there was only marching. The “shared load” technique began to pay off. Faith’s crew of four began to pass several of the individuals on other teams. Only the men carrying the cables were ahead of them as they approached the Division Headquarters and their next stop. As the passed one soldier from the platoon struggling under the weight of a tripod, the man called out “hey, that’s cheating!” “How?” asked the soldier carrying the MGS with LT Faith. The other man had no reply.

Faith’s team had a good rest while they waited for the rest of the platoon to arrive at the Division HQ. By now the platoon had moved about five and a half miles from the start position. Everyone, even Sergeant Ellery, seemed exhausted. The morale of the platoon was high, though; the comraderie and the spirit of competition were carrying them through the tough times.

“Good technique, sir,” Ellery said to Faith. “OK folks,” he shouted when the last members of the platoon finally straggled in. “OK folks, pair off into buddy teams. The next exercise will be… THE SITUP!”

After completing 101 four-count situps, Faith’s abs felt as sore and exhausted as the rest of him. During the break, Faith’s team decided that during the final leg of the race they would place the MGS on top of the tripod and launcher, effectively turning it into a litter. They would also use the cables to tie down the MGS so that it didn’t slide off during movement. Using this technique, the weight of the equipment was borne by only two people at a time, giving the other two the opportunity to rest somewhat during the move. The two not carrying the equipment walked to the left and right of the two men doing the carrying in order to maintain contact with the equipment. When the men carrying the load became exhausted, they would swap out with the two men on the outside, and the process would continue.

Seeing the success of the technique, the other crews in the race emulated it to varying degrees. But Faith’s team had a sizeable lead as they approached the turn-end point and the end of the 8-mile “death run.” Faith was feeling pretty confident, but when he turned to look behind him he saw Ellery’s team moving up fast.

“Oh shit, here comes Ellery,” Faith exclaimed, “Guys, we’re going to have to pick it up!” There wasn’t much left in the tank physically, but Faith’s team managed to gut it out at a slow shuffle and pass through the gate into the turn-in point just ahead of Ellery’s team. Both teams turned off into a grassy area just inside the gate, set their gear down, and collapsed on the ground.

“Holy shit I’m smoked,” said Hickman, echoing how everyone else felt.

There was a bit of a lag between the time Faith’s and Ellery’s teams arrived, and that of the other teams. First and Second Squads came in first, which meant Faith’s team won overall. When everyone arrived, Sergeant Ellery led the group in 125 four-count flutter kicks. By the time they were done, Faith felt completely exhausted. Between the 8 mile run with TOW equipment, and the hundreds of repetitions of pushups, situps, and flutter kicks, Faith was, like the rest of the platoon, completely exhausted.

Faith was happy his team won the team event, but he didn’t PMCS vehicles anyway so the idea of having a different team do PMCS for him was moot. What he really wanted was the three-day pass.

“There are water fountains inside the turn-in point,” Ellery stated. Hydrate up, and report back here in 15 minutes for the run back.” Ugh, that’s right. They still had to run the eight miles back to the company area. Faith was NOT looking forward to that. Ellery and Faith took a spot at the end of the line to get water, but the line moved quickly and Faith soon drank his fill. He still felt a headache coming on, a sure indicator that he was dehydrated. The run back was NOT going to be fun. Faith just hoped he could make it without passing out.

After the water break, the platoon formed up for the crew competition, to see who could get a TOW assembled an into action the quickest. Unfortunately, Faith was of little help in this, as his knowledge of the TOW was extremely limited. Having the LT on the team turned out to be a liability, and a crew from 3rd Squad won the three-day pass.

After the competition, Sergeant Ellery supervised the turn-in of the TOW equipment, receiving a stack of paperwork in return. He then had the platoon form up in the parking lot, where two 5-ton trucks had arrived during the time they were doing the turn-in.

“At ease! Good job, men,” he told the assembled group. “That was a lot more fun than I thought it was going to be.” Faith agreed. He was tired, and knew that his body would be sore in the morning, but this was a great chance to work with the men in the platoon and to see what they were made of. It was a real “gut check.” But it was not over yet. They still had eight more miles to go…

“We’re going to head on back home now,” Ellery explained. Faith prepared himself mentally for the long run back. He hoped it would be slow.

“Platoon, atten…tion!” Ellery commanded. “Right, face!” The platoon was now facing the 5-ton trucks. Ellery paused.

“OK, mount the trucks,” he said with a smile. There was a second of not understanding, and then the realization hit that they were not going to have to run eight miles, and the expressions of gratitude began. “Yesss….” Faith thought as he lined up to get in the back of the first truck.

“You’re up front, sir,” said Sergeant Spence.

Faith hesitated. “I don’t want to ride in a comfy seat when everyone else is bouncing around in the back on a hard bench,” he responded.

“Driver needs a TC,” Spence explained, using the acronym for “truck commander.” “You’re the highest ranking, sir.”

Well, the 101st Blue Book standard operating procedure did specify that the highest-ranking person would ride in the front as the TC during all vehicular movement. Faith begrudgingly hoped up into the passenger seat of the lead 5-ton. Sergeant Ellery did the same in the other truck. Despite his best intentions, Faith fell asleep almost as soon as the truck started moving. It had already been a very long day.
 
Despite the faux pas of falling asleep while serving as TC, the trip back to the company are was thankfully uneventful. Faith woke up when the truck stopped moving. “End of the line, sir,” said the driver. Faith thanked him and then slid down out of the truck. His legs were already sore from the morning’s PT session, not a good sign. He moved around to the back of the truck and helped a few soldiers down.

Because of the lengthy PT session and the turn-in of the TOW systems, the platoon was getting back well after PT hours had officially ended. It wasn’t a big deal, it just meant that the platoon would be getting a later start on their day. The soldiers on the meal plan missed breakfast in the chow hall, but none of them seemed concerned about it.

Ellery dismissed the platoon for showers, and he and Faith went inside the company area to put the turn-in paperwork on the First Sergeant’s desk and to see if any of note had happened while they were gone. It had been a slow morning. Ellery needed to grab something out of the office, so Faith exited the back door to go to his car, which was parked in the back lot.

As he exited the building, he stretched and took a deep breath. He was sore, and his body was going to punish him for what he did to it today. But he felt good. He felt a sense of accomplishment with a job well done at PT, and he felt genuinely accepted by the men of the platoon. It was going to be a good week. Plus Lilith, his girlfriend, was coming up from school to spend the weekend with him. Yes, it was going to be a good week, indeed.

His mood quickly soured, though, when he exited the building. The back of the company was sheltered somewhat from the back parking lot, partly by the design of the building and also by a pair of large dumpsters. A knot of Soldiers was congregated between the dumpsters and a corner of the building. Faith was surprised to see anyone at all back there during this time of day; usually, this was the time when literally everyone in the company was eating chow or recovering from PT and getting ready for the day.

The space behind the company area was small, and Faith was only a few steps away from the group when he exited the building. There were four or five individuals dressed in their gray Army physical fitness uniforms clustered around another individual who was on the ground. The standing group was taking turns slapping and kicking the individual on the ground. Faith knew who that person had to be.

“Hey, knock that shit off,” Faith said loudly. When the group turned to face him, Faith saw Thigpen on the ground, the “usual suspects” from 2nd Platoon, and one face he didn’t expect.

“This is the second time you’ve involved yourself in my platoon’s business,” growled Sergeant First Class Manners, 2nd Platoon’s platoon sergeant, plainly angry at the interruption. “You keep it up, you might find yourself more involved than you want to be.”

It wasn’t a direct threat per se, but its meaning was clear. Faith was more stunned than scared. He expected this kind of behavior from the lower enlisted, but not from a senior NCO. NCOs were supposed to prevent this kind of behavior, not encourage it.

“That’s going to have to be a platoon thing, then,” came a now-familiar voice from behind him. Faith didn’t even have to turn around to know it was Ellery. Faith didn’t want to fight. He was tired. Moreover, despite his initial deep dislike of the man, over the couple of weeks he had been in Delta Company, Faith had come to respect Sergeant Manners. And he definitely didn’t want to fight a guy he respected, while he was tired, over a genuine dirtbag like Thigpen. But Faith was a man of both pride and principle. He wasn’t afraid to throw hands if the situation required.


“Thigpen, get up and get your ass out of here,” Faith instructed.

“You stay where you are, Private!” Manners snapped. “This is Second Platoon business. When it becomes 5th Platoon business, we’ll let you know… sir!”

At about this time a group of 5th Platoon’s members, on the way to try to score breakfast from the local shoppette, happened by. “Hey sir! Great PT this morning. Need anything from the shoppette?”

Faith waved them off. Sensing something was off, the 5th Platoon Soldiers drew closer.

“Um… are we OK here Sarge?” they asked Ellery. Noticing the odds taking a turn out of their favor, the group from 2nd Platoon seemed willing to break contact.

“It kind of looks like this is about to be everybody’s business,” Ellery said to Manners. “If you don’t want this to be First Sergeant’s business too, I think everybody better take a deep breath and let… whatever this is… go.”

“If you like this shitbag so much, why don’t YOU take him, then?” challenged Manners.

“Nope, you handle your business, Sergeant,” replied Ellery firmly.

Manners lunged towards Ellery. “This is it,” Faith thought to himself, imagining that a platoon-on-platoon brawl was about to erupt. “This is how half of the platoon-level leadership in Delta Company gets relieved.” But Manners just got in Ellery's face, no hands were thrown. Manners looked furious. For his part, Edwards stood firm, his arms crossed over his chest. He seemed totally calm and unconcerned.

“Handle my business? That’s what I was fucking doing, Ellery,” Manners hissed. He then turned and glared at Faith before walking off.

Corporal Laser helped Thigpen up off the ground. “Pigpen, you’ve got to start sticking up for yourself,” he said. “5th Platoon’s not always going to be there for you.”

“You’ve got to take matters into your own hands, bro,” added Specialist Stringer.

“Come on Pigpen, let’s go get some chow,” said a third 5th Platoon Soldier.

After everyone else departed, Ellery sighed deeply. “Sir, I think we should have a talk,” Ellery said to Faith.

-----

1) This is at least the second time that LT Faith almost got into a brawl with Soldiers from 2nd Platoon. What are your thoughts on that?

2) What do you think Ellery and Faith are going to talk about?
 
Last edited:
1) This is wild and something I never encountered in my time. However, it sounds like something that would happen rather often. At some point he will need to use his chain and get that kid out of the company or chaptered out of the Army. If Soldiers didn't meet standards, we used the tools that that regulations gave us and we kicked dudes out.

2) Ellery might about save his LTs life right now.
 
“Nope, you handle your business, Sergeant,” replied Ellery firmly.

Manners lunged towards Edwards. “
Inquiring minds want to know...are Ellery and Edwards the same guy?

1) Never experienced that sort of rivalry...at the end of our involvement in Vietnam, there was tremendous racial tension in the Army (a reflection of the racial tension in our society), and that would get out of hand frequently, but I never saw that sort of tension between platoons...As far as the LT in the case study goes, in my opinion, he is right to intervene...
2) One of two things...Ellery might suggest that LT Faith mind his own business or he may suggest taking Thigpen into the platoon...personally, I would have had a visit with the 2nd Platoon leader and would be strongly considering taking the issue up with the company commander...
 
Last edited:
1) Never have I seen an enlisted person talk to a LT or any officer like that. That SFC had better like to be a Pvt all over again as he gets his ass chaptered out. As far as Faith goes, he needs to learn to use his rank. I am a proponent of both respecting the rank and the person. While you may not always like them, you must respect what is on their collar/sleeve.

2) I think Faith and Ellery are going to talk about using rank and hopefully charging Manners under Art 15. Paper sucks but if he's willing to disrespect an officer in the public of others, every action has consequences. Lower enlisted can get away with platoon fights, officers and senior enlisted cannot.
 
Back
Top