Case Study: Tabs and Tyrants

Received once, never bestowed. By the letter of the law, yes it is hazing. However, if both parties are in agreement, and it doesn’t get out of hand or malicious, then let them follow an old tradition.

I’m not sure how Faith would bring it up, but I’d feel it out over some coffee in the PSG’s office one morning if I were him. After all, he didn’t let any of the other joes draw blood. Most people think of hazing as being exponentially more violent than one good lick from the platoon daddy, even though the rules explicitly state otherwise. I think it has diminished the regard Faith had for SFC Ellery, but it remains to be seen by how much.

As far as memorizing the orders and whatnot, yeah, that matters. Either they’re going to believe that the new LT actually gives a damn, he’s got a 90lb brain in that cranium, or all of the above. Hell, I’m impressed that he did it.
 
Received for jump wings, never given it to anyone. I personally don't see it as hazing. I see it more as a rite of passage.

If the LT sees it as hazing, he should ban it from being done ever again. I feel it may have diminished his regard for his PSG, but I don't think by much.

It means a whole lot. I feel it is very important in terms of maintaining a professional Army, and it maintains tradition within the respective ranks.
 
I've been on both ends of earning a blood stripe. I don't think it should be mandatory, however with that being said, those who don't participate may be viewed as less than equal at first. I have never seen lower ranks give blood wings to higher ranks and do not think that is appropriate and is counterintuitive to the point.

If the LT doesn't agree with it, it is well within his rights that such activities do not happen.
 
Received and given....depends on the unit and participates. Usually it becomes a problem when it is over-zealously done and someone is being a prick about it. Didn't see it done around 2008...a fading tradition.
 
-----
1) Blood pinning: have you done it? Have you had it done to you? Do you consider it hazing?

2) Faith clearly believes that this was hazing. What, if anything, should he do about it? Does this diminish the regard with which he formerly held Sergeant Ellery?

3) Memorizing things like promotion orders and the oath of enlistment… does it mean something to the troops or is it a waste of time?

1. Blood pinning...no. We didn't have collar rank when I commissioned. When officers were promoted from 2LT to 1LT and to CPT all of their peers punched them lightly in the chest. And I mean lightly. When Soldiers were promoted in 1-1 CAV I don't even remember that occurring.

Would I consider blood pinning hazing? I don't know. You still have these kids at West Point that willingly blood pin each other on branch night and it ends up on Facebook. We did not do that at VMI. There was a time where blood pinning was a battle rhythm event every time a Soldier was promoted.

2. They need to have a conversation about platoon culture. If this is something he doesn't want going on, it's his platoon and he needs to facilitate that. But should there be some type of right of passage. I remember my CO wanted to create a training event that served as an initiation for Soldiers incoming to the Troop, I thought that was interesting for a variety of reasons.

3. My troop retention NCO and I fucked up the first re-enlistment I did. We had just gotten back from our mid-way point of Gunnery and he put something on the schedule...and then the SCO released everyone early. And this Soldier was at the Wash rack at the time. But the real fuck up is that I had not memorized the oath...my Senior Scout scolded the shit out of me. Every re-enlistment I did after that was having memorized the oath of enlistment.
 
1.) Kinda. Jump wings and CIB were blood pinned. For promotions, the ACU velcro thing supposedly threw a wrench in old traditions. So we just gut/thorax punched the awardee on the newly velcroed rank.

Most of the platoon would give you a love tap and a hug, few people would take it a bit further. Doc would always give you a hug. Regardless, it was one punch per person. Bruising wasn't uncommon, but it'd go away after a week or two. It was a communal thing, so what went around came around.

Looking back I guess it was hazing, but in a weird way it was a point of pride and cohesion for many. Especially when you're alone as a platoon, you build bonds and create rituals of belonging amongst yourselves.

2.) Aware or not, Faith unintentionally took part in what he considers hazing. Best thing to do is learn from that lesson and drive on. If he really needs clarification he needs to link up with Ellery and hash things out. No point in stewing on things.

3.) It's not always necessary, but it's the little details that can really boost a units trust and morale. On flip side, someone reciting perfectly memorized words can still be a dirtbag, if they don't mean or live by what they parrot. We've all run into those the types of people.
 
That evening after final formation, Sergeant Ellery had 5th Platoon stand fast. “Specialist Wilson! Front and center!”

“Moving, Sergeant!” said Wilson enthusiastically, taking one step backwards out of his squad line and then double timing to face Ellery.

“Parade, REST!” Ellery commanded as the rest of the company began to drift away for the evening.

“5th Platoon,” Ellery said loudly, “You are here after everyone else has gone home today because of Specialist Wilson. You can blame him for what happens next.” Wilson, and the rest of the platoon, looked at Ellery in confusion. Wilson NEVER got in trouble.

“Specialist Wilson,” Ellery continued, “Is out of uniform. What are we going to do about that, sir?” he called back to Lieutenant Faith.

They had rehearsed this with the other NCOs prior to formation. Faith knew his lines: “Well we better get his entire chain of command up there to fix it, Sergeant!”

“Roger that, sir. Platoon—Atten…tion!” Ellery bellowed. When the still-confused platoon snapped to rigid attention, Ellery executed a crisp about-face. Faith marched around the left side of his platoon on a position in front of Ellery. Ellery saluted and Faith returned the salute. “NCOs, take your post!” Faith ordered. This was a non-standard drill and ceremony order, but because of the rehearsal the NCOs knew what to do. The lined up behind Wilson, who was facing Faith and had no idea what was happening behind him. “Specialist Wilson,” Faith called out, “About… FACE!” Wilson executed the ordered movement and found himself face to face with a line of three men: his team leader, his squad leader, and his platoon sergeant. A smile began to creep over his face as recognition of what was happening started to sink in.

“Attention to orders,” Faith intoned, “The Secretary of the Army has reposed special trust and confidence in the patriotism, valor, fidelity and professional excellence of the Specialist Jason A. Wilson. In view of these qualities and their demonstrated leadership potential and dedicated service to the United States Army, they are, therefore, promoted to the rank of sergeant, effective today.” He did it from memory, with no notes.

As Faith spoke, the NCOs in front of Wilson removed the new NCO’s specialist insignia and tossed it over their shoulders. It made a faint *ting!* noise when they struck the asphalt. Sergeant Ellery motioned for Faith to join the line, and Specialist Wilson’s platoon sergeant and new platoon leader pinned on his triple-chevron insignia of a buck sergeant. Faith went to put the metal backings on the sharp pins of the insignia, but Ellery waved him off. “Not yet, sir,” he whispered.

“5th Platoon,” Ellery stated, “Fall out and join me in congratulating the Army’s newest NCO, Sergeant Jason Wilson!” The platoon erupted in cheers. Wilson was a popular and well-liked junior leader within the platoon. A line formed to congratulate Wilson. Faith was first. He exchanged salutes with Wilson and shook his hand. “Congratulations, Sergeant,” he said.

Ellery followed Faith. Faith watched as Ellery squared up to Wilson. “Are you ready, Sergeant?” he asked.

“Roger, Sarn’t,” Wilson said, enthusiastically but with a little uncertainty. The rest of the platoon seemed to know what was about to happen, even if Faith did not.

“Oh damn, you’re going to get it now!”

“Get ‘im, Sergeant Ellery!”

“Time to bring the pain!”

Without further warning, Ellery brought down both hands in a thunderous thud onto Wilson’s collar, directly onto the pins which Faith knew due to the fact that they were still in his hand, did not have the metal backs over the sharp pins.

Having experienced “blood pinning” many times in college and in Army schools, Faith imagined he felt the pins going into Wilson’s skin when he heard the whump made by Ellery’s hands. Wilson took a step back with one foot after the impact and looked a little surprised but otherwise seemed fine. Ellery popped up the collar of Wilson’s uniform and motioned for Faith. “Sir?” he asked. Faith handed over the metal pin backs and put them on the pins. He then smoothed out Wilson’s collar. “OK,” he said, beckoning to the rest of the platoon.

Having seen the walloping that Wilson just received from Ellery, most of the rest of the platoon simply shook his hand. A few, however, clapped Wilson on the collar in the same manner that Sergeant Ellery did. But with the back on the pins, the blows were harmless. For his part, Staff Sergeant David, Wilson’s squad leader, patted him lightly on the collar. “Good job, Sergeant. I’m proud of you.”

The last group of soldiers waiting to congratulate the Army’s newest sergeant was a group of specialists, Wilson’s now-former running buddies within the platoon. They were clearly planning… something.

“You either die a hero, or live long enough to become a villain,” one of them joked. “You are hereby excommunicated from the Spec-4 Mafia!” exclaimed another. “You’re one of them now, sergeant,” said a third. While they all tried to carry a menacing tone, it was clear that they were happy that Wilson was getting promoted. One of them went up to Wilson and began removing the backings from his sergeant rank. They clearly wanted in on the blood pinning.

“If you take those backs off after Sergeant Ellery put them on, the next thing to come off is your head,” warned Corporal Laser. After considering it for a moment, the specialist decided that discretion was the better part of valor on this issue. “You’re lucky,” he said to Wilson with a wink. “OK everyone, let’s head to the all-ranks, drinks are on Sergeant Wilson!”

“Not so fast,” said Sergeant Ellery. “Fall back in.”

After the platoon was re-assembled, Sergeant Ellery addressed the troops. “Men, this is a great occasion. I’m proud to have Sergeant Wilson as a fellow NCO. The last event to take place during an NCO promotion is a recitation of the NCO Creed. I invite all NCOs to say it with me:




“Sir, you have anything?” he asked of Faith.

“Negative, Sergeant,” Faith responded.

“Platoon… dis-missed! Make good decisions tonight. Remember the rank that the Army gives on Thursday can be taken away on Friday.”

“Sergeant Ellery fucked you up, Wilson!” Faith heard one of the specialists say as they walked off towards the all-ranks club. “That’s SERGEANT Wilson to you!” another specialist jokingly corrected.

After the promotion, Faith and Ellery headed back to their shared office to finish up a few loose ends. Faith was slightly troubled by the blood pinning. Ellery seemed like such a by-the-book kind of NCO. But blood pinning, while widespread and, honestly, even expected in the Infantry, was also specifically banned as hazing. More out of curiosity than anything else, he decided to ask Ellery about it.

“So blood pinning is a thing here?” he asked.

“Not really, sir,” Ellery responded.

“Do you worry that you might set a bad example to the troops by blood pinning someone in front of the who platoon? Or that someone might dime you out to the sergeant major over it?”

“I’ve never ‘blood pinned’ anyone in my entire life,” he countered.

“I just saw you do it, Sergeant Ellery!” Faith exclaimed.

“Did you, sir?” Ellery inquired. “If there’s nothing else, I think I’ll head home. It’s been a pretty long day. See you at PT tomorrow?”

Faith nodded.

“Never blood pinned anyone?? WTF was THAT supposed to mean?” Faith wondered as he went to the car and headed for the Officers’ Club and a much-needed beer.

-----
1) Blood pinning: have you done it? Have you had it done to you? Do you consider it hazing?

2) Faith clearly believes that this was hazing. What, if anything, should he do about it? Does this diminish the regard with which he formerly held Sergeant Ellery?

3) Memorizing things like promotion orders and the oath of enlistment… does it mean something to the troops or is it a waste of time?
1. Yes and I don’t consider it hazing. Wings, EIB and CIB were all pounded in, by people I respect. Is is it hazing? Legally yes. Anyone who would actually complain about it doesn’t warrant the award/piece of flare they’re receiving.

2.He needs to let that one slide. He shouldn’t think less of the PSG- it just lets him know this guy is “old school” and he needs to manage him accordingly.

3.Memorizing shit like that is lame. It does not impress the men. Everyone here knows the Ranger creed because it’s a great manifestation of esprit de Corps and is actually worth living by. Army regs, not so much.
 
Punching/ pushing it vs. pounding it in are two different things. Hazing is..subjective.
Too right.


When I got my crab, it’s surprising that my buddy didn’t catch a sex offense charge, because he pinned it and puuuuuuuuuushed. I was cool with it. We even agreed ahead of the graduation ceremony. Thankful there were no pussies in attendance to say he was grabbing my boob.

Now, one of my former PL’s got fucked up when he got his senior badge at my unit. His orders came down before mine, so I didn’t get in on it. He wound up with a fractured collar bone, and he played dumb at the TMC. Blood crabs in my unit stopped after that one, and there was rumor that a 15-6 was coming down the pipeline. No leadership changes happened, so I’m not sure if an investigation ever happened.

Hate to see how they’d have done someone they didn’t like.
 
The next morning after first formation, Ellery and Faith met with Wilson to discuss his potential move to a different platoon. Faith knew that Ellery wanted to send Wilson to 2nd Platoon, the company’s “problem-child” outfit. But Faith had misgivings. He wanted to set the newly-promoted Sergeant Wilson up for success, and sending him to literally the worst platoon in the company didn’t seem like a good way to do that.

Seated in their tiny office, Ellery began the conversation bluntly enough. “Sergeant Wilson, you know that my policy is to move new NCOs out of the platoon. We’ve discussed the rationale for that policy before. Do you have any questions about it?”

“No, sar’nt,” Wilson said in his slow Georgia drawl. “I don’t want to leave 5th Platoon, but I get why I need to move. It’s hard to go from “one of us” as a Joe to “one of them” as an NCO.”

Ellery nodded. “OK, then, have you given any decision to where you might want to go?”

“Second Platoon,” Wilson said without hesitation. “I think they need me the most.”

Ellery nodded again. “Sir?” he asked Faith.

Faith was a little surprised by how quickly Wilson made the decision to do the “harder right over the easier wrong.” Second Platoon really did need him more.

Faith had a long argument worked out in his head as to why Wilson shouldn’t go to 2nd, but with both Ellery and Wilson making the recommendation, he decided to let it go. “That’s fine with me if it’s good with you and First Sergeant,” he responded.

“OK, that’s settled then,” Ellery stated. “Sergeant Wilson, pack up your stuff and report to Sergeant Manners after lunch.”

Wilson nodded and stood up to leave.

“One more thing, Sergeant,” Faith said, stopping him.

Reaching down into his black backpack, he pulled out a framed copy of the Creed of the Noncommissioned Officer which had been personalized with Wilson’s name.

“I wanted you to have this, from the platoon,” Faith told him.


1584909357647.png



Wilson held the frame in hands and looked over it. “This is really cool, sir, thanks!” he said enthusiastically. “Do you… do you think you and Sergeant Ellery could sign the back?” Faith thought the request was unusual but didn’t see any harm in it. “Of course,” he replied, reaching into his desk drawer and pulling out a black Sharpie marker.

After Wilson left with his autographed copy of the NCO Creed, Sergeant Ellery looked at Lieutenant Faith. “Wilson was right, that was a pretty cool thing to do, especially saying that it came from the platoon and not just from you.”

“Glad to do it,” said Faith. “It took me an hour total, and most of that was the drive back and forth to WalMart to get the frame. Five minutes on my laptop and one sheet of paper off my home printer.”

“It’s the thought that counts,” Ellery reminded him. “That’s probably something he’s going to keep his entire career.”

-----------

1) What kinds of small positive gestures do you recall from your career?

2) Conversely, what little things did you observe, do, or have done to you that had a lasting negative effect?
 
The arrival of Sergeant Wilson seemed to be a breath of fresh air into the life of Second Platoon. The platoon’s overall performance seemed to inch upward with every passing day. This wasn’t all attributable to Wilson, of course, but he definitely helped. His enthusiasm and no-nonsense approach to leadership freed up other leaders in the platoon to concentrate on things that they had long neglected. It was an example of the positive impact that one motivated and caring leader can have on a unit.

The one thing that neither Wilson, nor anyone else in Second Platoon seemed to be able to do anything about, was the platoon problem child, Private Thigpen, AKA “Pigpen.” Sergeant First Class Manners made Sergeant Wilson a team leader, and put Pigpen on Wilson’s team. Pigpen became Wilson’s personal project. He basically became Pigpen’s private trainer. He helped Pigpen develop a physical fitness plan, and healthy eating plan, and a “cleanliness” regimen. He supervised Pigpen during PT, went to the chow hall with him for breakfast, inspected his barracks room daily, and constantly drove him to perform.

This had immediate, but unfortunately not long-lasting, results. When under the close and direct supervision of Sergeant Wilson, Private Thigpen performed. His barracks room was spotless. His physical fitness increased. He began to lose weight. He even took a shower every day… and used soap. But whenever Wilson would ease up, Thigpen would backslide. When Wilson unexpectedly got a slot to Ranger School shortly after joining Second Platoon, Thigpen went right back to his Pigpen ways.

Faith sought Sergeant Wilson out the day before the latter left for Ranger School to wish him good luck and to ask him if he had any questions or concerns about what he was going to face. Although Faith never graduated from Ranger School, he felt like he spent enough time there to at least know the ropes.

“I don’t know, sir,” Wilson explained hesitatingly. “Second Platoon really isn’t that bad. I think Sergeant Manners just needed another NCO he could trust on board to help get the problem children all straightened out.”

“But,” he added, “Private Thigpen… sir he really is a complete dumbass. He can’t do anything right, unless I’m right there to put a boot in his ass.

“Well,” Faith said, “I think you’re right. He’s probably never going to be a great Soldier, but maybe we can help him be an adequate one. That’s one of our jobs as leaders.”

Wilson nodded. “You’re right sir. It’s just a big pain in the ass right now. I’m really worried about what might happen to him while I’m gone.”

“Wilson, you can’t worry about stuff like that,” Faith admonished. “When you’re at Ranger School, you need to have one thing on your mind: graduating Ranger School. You worry about that, and that alone. Pigpen is going to have to stand or fall on his own.”

“I wish people wouldn’t call him that,” Wilson replied sadly.

“Call him what?” Faith inquired.

“Pigpen,” Wilson responded. He’s not a bad guy, he’s just really, really dumb. Like, I think he’s legitimately retarded or something. But not in a mean way. He’s not cut out for the Army but I don’t think he could function anywhere else in society, either.”

Faith thought about that for a moment. He didn’t even realize that he had called Thigpen “Pigpen.” It was just so… natural.

“Look,” Faith said, “I’ll… check in on Private Thigpen while you’re gone. I’m not going to do the things that you’re doing for him, but at least he’ll know that someone else cares. When you get back, though, you probably need to think about recommending some chapter paperwork to get this guy out of the military. You can’t be his big brother forever.”

That’s where they left it, with Faith promising to check in on Thigpen and Wilson agreeing to not come back without his Ranger Tab.

-----
Discussion questions:
1) Nicknames: a net good for the organization, or a net bad? Were you ever in a unit where nicknames were prohibited?

2) If you served in a unit where nicknames were popular, what was the process for assigning / earning a nickname?

3) What was your nickname?
 
1. Depends on the soldier whether a nickname is a good idea or not. If the soldier is a shitbag and you want to change his behavior, I don't think you validate it by calling him shitbag. That's not going to build his confidence. Good soldiers can take it because they already have self confidence.
 
The Australian Army is nickname central.
Run of the mill last name or contraction of last name with O or IE on the end, Simmo, Jamesie, Smithy, Ryano, Youngy, then Tiny, or Lofty for tall blokes, Blue for blokes with red hair, also FOT (Fucking Orange Thing) gets a run, Shorty for short arses, anyone named Tailor was called Squizzy, if you inevitably had several Squizzes you'd seperate them into Big Squiz and Little Squiz. Anyone called Walker was called Phantom. Anyone from Eastern Europe with too many vowels in their name was called Wheelbarrow with a * insert first letter of name. Big powerful buggers get Donk (character in the Crocodile Dundee movies) or Horse, if your last name is Wellington, you get called Boots.
Unpopular Officers would be saddled with FINCL or of FONC (fucking idiot no cunt likes, or friend of no cunt). And there is a Federal Senator for New South Wales by the name of Drugs, who picked up his nickname while taking his Battalion on 6 monthly 80km pack marches.
Then the day to day casual references for each other, ball bag, shit lips, cock breath, fuck nose, cunt, knacker bags, fuck head. But if you called a bloke champ, you might be in for a fight.
 
1. Nicknames are good, as long as not demeaning. Never prohibited in units I was in.
2. Process was...someone just called you the name and if it stuck, as in used by others...it stuck.
3. Kraut

From my experiences in the military and police, it was a sign of acceptance into the brotherhood.

Funny family history thing...my last name is Goehring, my father was a USAF fighter pilot...his given nickname was "Hermie" as in Reichmarshal Herman Goering.
 
Last edited:
1) A Parker Short V-42 was a Christmas gift from my Company CO one year, It went right onto my LBE on the Left front H-riser under my Battle dressing. I still have it and the original sheath in my collection. The only mod I made to it (besides a proper sharpening) was wrapping the handle with 550 cord for grip.
2) The Team assigned Nicknames, and changed them depending on situation.
3) Can't even remember them all... but The Troll stuck.
 
Nicknames are a very powerful thing and I think much more powerful than a lot of people realise. They can- intentionally or unintentionally- either include or exclude a person very quickly and can massively affect a person's emotional state at work for better or for worse.

In this case it's derision that's driving the pigpen nickname. Stamping that out would be a good way to bring him back to the flock and might encourage behaviour without the sgt there. You can see by the capt. using it unintentionally how easy it is for the group think mentality to slip in and can create a "me and them" mindset, which might be half of Thigpen's problems. Either way, anyone in the chain of command has an obligation to do the best for him that they can and derogatory nicknames aren't part of that.

We do nicknames. A lot come from variations of names and initials but there is one derogatory one that in use. He doesn't like it so I don't use it.
 
My last deployment, we had a "Marine" who didn't want to be in the Corps. He spent everyday trying to convince the psychiatrists he was crazy so they would send him CONUS. He was able to shit his pants whenever he wanted and that was the final straw for the psych docs. They sent him home. His name was Capra, so of course the Marines called him "Crapra".
 
1. Depends....and as for prohibition, such an edict would only have incited nicknaming...2. Some were derivations of names, such as T.J. or Steve or Queenie (SGT McQueen hated that)...others were earned...we had a Pigpen...he did not own any item of clothing that wasn't grease stained, food stained or otherwise...3. Steve and Volume...
 
Back
Top