Here's the remainder of the comment Worldweaver posted earlier:
Okay this guy has me fired up. I'm willing to bet he doesn't have a tab or even made the attempt.
First off, just being ok and good enough doesn't cut it. Task, condition, standard, period. Often, good enough doesn't cut it. RI is looking for more than that.
A cold weather casualty who I helped revive got go'd at Darby while I recycled. I recycled because patrols were substandard. It didn't matter that I had helped save my Ranger buddy... That's an expectation. I didn't meet the graded expectation of having good patrols. I eventually got my act together and graduated.
That guy has no idea how Rangers, Ranger school graduates, or any SOF soldier feels about this issue.
He can cry into his Cheerios all he wants, but he is sullying his wife's reputation. He needs to keep his mouth shut. I'm willing to bet most of those ladies will step up and admit they failed to meet the standard, and that is that. They will always be non-grads who say they got screwed. Good on all the attendees for trying. The pioneers catch the first arrows.