Case Study: Sun Tzu, III/31

I was afraid of that, I didn't transition effectively.

OK, so you read in the previous case studies about the MID going to Iraq, and then coming back, the issues with CPT James, etc. Shortly after the beginning of this case study, there was a flashback to explain how CPT Faith got the MID Cdr job, and to introduce background on some of the key characters. The last story-related post I made marked the end of the flashback, and we're now back to the point in the story where we would have been had the flashback never occurred. I'll work on it.
 
Almost a year later, at a party to celebrate the return of 2nd Group from an arduous deployment to Iraq, Faith had a chance to reflect upon the events that had occurred since he first arrived. Faith was greatly entertained by the way in which Soldiers in the MID retold the stories about the MID’s travails in dealing with The Dud and the difficulties they faced during their deployment. As the night grew longer, Faith noticed that the tales were getting taller. Having been personally present for the events being related, he knew they were in some cases being wildly exaggerated. But they were entertaining nonetheless, and Faith did nothing to correct them.

A lot had happened in the past year; on top of the combat losses suffered by the Group, several retirements, promotions, and other rotations had occurred. MSG Marion, the long-serving detachment sergeant of the MID, had been replaced by Master Sergeant Reynolds, who was laterally appointed to First Sergeant when the MID went from being a “detachment” to a “company” (although everyone still referred to it as the MID; the acronym MIC was, perhaps, too pejorative). Reynolds was Faith’s right hand during some extremely difficult times (see: case studies The Loving Wife, The Soul Plane Incident, and Karma). But now Reynolds was on his way out as well, having come down on the list for promotion to Sergeant Major.

The Group Commander had rotated out, and Chief Michaels, for so long Faith’s champion within the Group, had retired. The DCO remained for now; his PCS out of the Group on hold until the new Commander got settled in. There were many new faces within the MID, as well.

Some things hadn’t changed, though; The Dud was still… The Dud. He and Faith maintained their general antipathy towards each other, but until recently, there had been far fewer big blow-ups between the two. The mutual animosity between the two officers and their respective shops remained though; that hadn’t changed. And despite the passage of time, the enablers within the MID still struggled for credibility with the Special Forces Soldiers they supported. On that last issue in particular, Faith wondered if was going to be able to make headway.

There was some good news, though. The 2nd Group MID had gone from being the laughingstock of USASFC to being one of the best. In fact, they were in the running for the SOCOM’s “intel enablers of the year” award. Faith also felt like he was on the cusp of convincing the 2nd Group leadership to initiate a Group-internal assessment, selection, and training program for intelligence personnel assigned to the Group. Faith envisioned this as something that would start off small, within 2nd Group, then expand to all the Groups individually, and then be adopted by the USASFC schoolhouse. Ultimately, it was the goal to have every enabler, not just the intel types, go through a program comparable to what the 18-series Special Forces troops went through, only specific to those respective enabler MOSs.

Faith knew he faced an uphill battle; he sensed that many in the Group were suspicious of any type of selection for enablers. In fact, the current Group Commander, a new arrival who Faith did not yet know well, expressed extreme skepticism. The new commander once remarked to Faith, “I don’t trust anything not wearing a tab,” meaning anyone who wasn’t Special Forces qualified. But Faith felt that the MID had really made its bones within the Group by providing what was almost universally regarded as an extraordinary level of support to the ODAs, the command group, the battalions and companies, and to the other staff sections. This gave Faith some hope that the gains in the relationships between intelligence enablers and the 18-series personnel they supported could be sustained, improved, and eventually utilized in order to implement some changes that, Faith felt, would have permanent positive effects.

Faith had closely coordinated with the friends he had made amongst the 18-series Soldiers in 2nd Group, and incorporated their insights and suggestions into his plan for the enabler selection. Some of them went so far as to volunteer to be part-time graders for the assessment and selection portions of the program, and to help train those who made it through the process. Consequently, Faith was optimistic that he would be given the opportunity to try out his plan, and for it to succeed or fail on its own merits.
When he briefed the new Group Commander, however, the man was unconvinced.

“You focus on the 50-meter target, Faith,” he instructed, “Your first priority is getting us through the annual intel inspection. You do that, and then we’ll talk more about this little pet project of yours. And about you being the new Group S2, after Major Dudley moves over to Division.”
 
Faith felt a little annoyed about his plan being referred to as a “pet project.” This was something that was going to be good for all of Group, and Faith wished more people would see it that way. He was also a little annoyed that the MID was still saddled with this responsibility, when it was in fact the S2’s job. That’s OK though, Faith thought, the MID would come through for the Group just like it had for the entire time he had been in command, and that would give him enough credibility with the new Group commander that he would finally be able to implement the new enabler screening program, which he was calling ASP, for Assessment and Selection Program.

By now, Faith and the other leaders of the MID, specifically First Sergeant Reynolds and Chief Rollins (now promoted to CW3), were presiding over a company which ran like a well-oiled machine. Most of the dead weight had been cut away, and the troops who were left were motivated, fit, experienced, and most of all, effective. Several of them, especially the SOT-As and CI personnel, were frequently “by-name requested” by certain ODAs for both training and deployments. Faith resisted the frequent urging of many team and even battalion commanders to “attach” certain members of the MID to battalions on a semi-permanent basis on the grounds that 1) it would reduce the flexibility of the MID to respond to contingencies elsewhere in the Groupd; and 2) it would, over time, decrease the effectiveness of the ODAs, who would over-concentrate on whatever it was that particular ODA needed at the time, to the detriment of other skills.

Preparation for the upcoming inspection went smoothly; at this point it was almost a battle drill for the MID. Small teams visited all of the arms rooms in the Group, and separate elements inspected battalion-level MIDs and SCIF areas. Chief Rollins herself pre-inspected the Group S2 shop which, unsurprisingly, required the most work. Faith wondered to himself how the S2 section could have gotten so bad. It was, he reckoned, a combination of unmotivated troops, ambiguous tasks, and poor leadership. The Dud was, of course, The Dud, but he would be gone after Faith took over as the Group S2. Of more concern was the S2 NCOIC. By MTOE, the S2 NCOIC was an 18Z, a highly experienced SF NCO with intelligence-specific training. In theory, this would be one of the most senior, most competent NCOs in the Group, whose input would be vital to shaping the intel support to the Group. In practice, the person put in that position was either 1) a guy who no one wanted as a team sergeant, 2) someone who was broken physically, or 3) someone marking time to retirement. Unfortunately for the S2 shop, their NCOIC, MSG Skeet, was all three.

Faith knew that when he took over as the Group S2, MSG Skeet would have to be the first one to go. Maybe he could get Skeet transferred over to the SCUBA locker, or to work with the sniper training section. Anything to get him out of the S2 shop; Faith would rather go short in that position than have someone who was actively bringing it down. There were others who would have to go too—officers, NCOs, and Soldiers who no one else bothered to take the time to drum out of Group, but instead sent to the Group S2 shop in order to get rid of them.

Long term, Faith saw the Group S2 shop as the first stop for all intel enablers assigned to the Group. Whether the Group officially sponsored it or not, Faith was pretty sure he’d be able to enact some type of ASP, if for no other reason than no one seemed to care about the enabler side of the house. After completing ASP, new intel enablers would spend some time in the Group S2 shop, until Faith and his NCOs felt that person was ready to go down to one of the battalions. The true dead weight in the S2 shop Faith would cut away; the marginal would stay in the Group S2 shop, and the good would go down to the battalions. Faith would assume risk at the Group level when it came to enabler performance; the best and brightest needed to be out in the field, supporting the ODAs.
 
Gad this thread is like a daytime soap opera! You can watch one day of them, come back a month later and STILL know what's going on... :wall:

LL - hoping I don't get banned for that remark...
 
As he entered the headquarters building and passed the commander’s office, Faith heard a noise that made his blood run cold. Emanating from the commander’s office was a series of guffaws and loud and speech that could only come from one person: Major Quentin Roberts. Faith recognized the voice immediately, and was immediately concerned.

Roberts had been Faith’s battalion XO in a previous assignment in Korea, and Faith couldn’t think of a more miserable excuse for an officer than Quintin Roberts. Even The Dud was exponentially better. At least The Dud was just stupid and lazy; Roberts was stupid and industrious. And he was morally bankrupt to boot. These are the worst kinds of officers in the world.

Faith paused in the hallway, stunned to hear Roberts’ voice and wondering what it meant. The door to the commander’s office opened, and Roberts emerged. If he was surprised to see Faith, he didn’t show it.

“And here he is, right here, sir!” Roberts exclaimed over his shoulder to the Group commander, who was behind him. Given the context, Faith assumed that some type of conversation had taken place between Roberts and the Group commander. “Great to see you again, Scotty!” he added, holding out a hand to Faith.

Faith, speechless, made no move to shake hands. For one thing, he loathed being called “Scotty.” That was what his mother called him when he was four. He had been “Scot” since pre-school. For another, he loathed Roberts, who among other things, had tried to have some Korean burial mounds bulldozed and had threatened to shoot another company commander over refusing to cut down a tree in Korea that blocked what Roberts thought was a “strategic and commanding view” of the street below. Roberts had also called the Group before and tried to find out information about Faith, most likely to try to sabotage Faith’s chances of taking command of the MID.

Roberts stood there for a second with his hand held out to Faith, then loudly exclaimed “Same ol’ Scotty!” before clapping Faith on the shoulder and making his way past. “See you around, soon,” he added ominously.

For his part, Faith resisted the urge to punch Roberts square in the face.

“You little cocksocker,” Faith said out loud to himself after Roberts was out of earshot, “what are you doing here?”

Before he turned to make his way back to the secretary’s office, Faith saw the Group commander standing in the doorway to his office, a disapproving look on his face.
 
Back
Top