National Protest and 'disband the cops' discussion (please review page 1)

Ooh-Rah said:
Why is it ridiculous?

Please, try to explain it to me/us?

Please know, this is not said with any sarcasm, snark, or anything else. Why is it (in your opinion) ridiculous to suggest that Antifa and Boog are analogous?
Click to expand...

Because if the question is in good faith, you've been ignoring pages worth of content regarding this topic in multiple threads.
 
Florida173 said:
Because if the question is in good faith, you've been ignoring pages worth of content regarding this topic in multiple threads.
Click to expand...
It is in good faith, but truthfully my eyes hurt after reading these political threads all day everyday. If I was not on staff here, I would ignore them all together. I read members arguing back and forth all day long about these groups. Who/what am I supposed to believe?

But okay @Florida173 , you've got my attention now. I've asked a question in good faith, you've deemed it "ridiculous" because .... I should have figured it out in the 49 pages of this thread?

Cool.

That out of the way, enlighten me/us? Just one last time?
Ooh-Rah said:
Is Boogaloo an extremist version of the right, the same way Antifa is an extremist version of the left?

If that is the case, has Trump declared Boogaloo a terrorist organization the same way he has Antifa?

Or is that part of the problem, we 'righties' are quick to blame Antifa for everything, but we won't acknowledge that Boogaloo even exists?
Click to expand...
 
Florida173 said:
Because if the question is in good faith, you've been ignoring pages worth of content regarding this topic in multiple threads.
Click to expand...

That's the worst non-answer I've seen in awhile. Defend your stance with facts, or don't make these statements, please.

Cite said posts at the very least.
 
Ooh-Rah said:
But okay @Florida173 , you've got my attention now. I've asked a question in good faith, you've deemed it "ridiculous" because .... I should have figured it out in the 49 pages of this thread?
Click to expand...

I don't blame you for not liking some of these threads. I was thinking the more than 280 posts regarding the subject since 2017 with a ton of content regarding it could help. There are some great articles from back in the day from around the world, some even critiquing them back in 2008. I love how they all share the same flags and have been well documented to be an international organization. Super active in Portland with the Rose City Antifa - Wikipedia

I believe arguments to their legitimacy of not being considered an organization is indeed ridiculous.

Regarding the boog bois or whatever they are calling themselves. Still in meme form and actions are lone-wolf as I stated before.
 
Florida173 said:
Regarding the boog bois or whatever they are calling themselves. Still in meme form and actions are lone-wolf as I stated before.
Click to expand...
Okay thank you. One more....and acknowledging ahead of time that they are not an 'official' organization. Is it fair to consider those who call themselves "Boog bois" to be an extreme for of Conservatism, the same way Antifa is considered an extreme form of Liberalism?

To add - thank you for all of the links in your prior post.
 
Ooh-Rah said:
Is it fair to consider those who call themselves "Boog bois" to be an extreme for of Conservatism, the same way Antifa is considered an extreme form of Liberalism?
Click to expand...

I'd say it's more complicated than that and it's quite an over-simplification that makes people decide on a false dilemma fallacy. One grew out of a 4chan joke and is trying to bring about a second Civil War because of a bunch of disenfranchised "patriots" think they are doing the right thing (nothing conservative about that) and one is hyper socialist anti-capitalist group pretending to be against nazis. Antifa has nothing to do with liberalism.
 
Florida173 said:
I'd say it's more complicated than that and it's quite an over-simplification that makes people decide on a false dilemma fallacy. One grew out of a 4chan joke and is trying to bring about a second Civil War because of a bunch of disenfranchised "patriots" think they are doing the right thing (nothing conservative about that) and one is hyper socialist anti-capitalist group pretending to be against nazis. Antifa has nothing to do with liberalism.
Click to expand...
Thanks you.

I sincerely appreciate you taking the time to explain your view on that.
 
Blizzard said:
I'm with others...I don't understand this whole Boogaloo thing, let alone what it has to do with Breakin' 2 Electric Boogaloo?!
Click to expand...
Electric Boogaloo was its own meme where you'd jokingly come up with an idea for a sequel that nobody wanted and slap 2: Electric Boogaloo at the end of the name. This lead to people saying Civil War 2: Electric Boogaloo which was eventually shortened to just Boogaloo. Its kind of an offshoot of another meme, which is why it seems disconnected.
 
Ooh-Rah said:
Okay thank you. One more....and acknowledging ahead of time that they are not an 'official' organization. Is it fair to consider those who call themselves "Boog bois" to be an extreme for of Conservatism, the same way Antifa is considered an extreme form of Liberalism?

To add - thank you for all of the links in your prior post.
Click to expand...
They are similar, but dissimilar.
Antifa-Socialists/Communists/Anarchists who need/want a Civil War so they can remake America. From what I've seen they are primarily white 20 somethings
KKK-Proud Boyz, et al. White supremacists who need/want a civil war so they can "return" America to the way it was (i.e. white protestants rule, everyone else kneels)
BLM-Black supremacists who want a race war they will win, allowing blacks to take over every aspect of government, and then put the white people "in their place"
Booger Boyz, loose groupings of right-wingers who believe we have strayed from the Constitution (especially 2A) and need a civil war to restore constitutional order.

1st 3 groupings are organized with outside funding (esp Antifa and BLM) the last group is still organizing and IMO not as big a threat as Antifa.
 
DA SWO said:
They are similar, but dissimilar.
Antifa-Socialists/Communists/Anarchists who need/want a Civil War so they can remake America. From what I've seen they are primarily white 20 somethings
KKK-Proud Boyz, et al. White supremacists who need/want a civil war so they can "return" America to the way it was (i.e. white protestants rule, everyone else kneels)
BLM-Black supremacists who want a race war they will win, allowing blacks to take over every aspect of government, and then put the white people "in their place"
Booger Boyz, loose groupings of right-wingers who believe we have strayed from the Constitution (especially 2A) and need a civil war to restore constitutional order.

1st 3 groupings are organized with outside funding (esp Antifa and BLM) the last group is still organizing and IMO not as big a threat as Antifa.
Click to expand...

Generally agree, but nothing racist in a multi cultured group like proud boys and to put them in with the kkk is crazy.

I also don't think BLM is a black supremacy organization. I'd say it's more of another system of control. It gets pretty messy when considering that the Black Lives Matter Global Foundation, Inc. is not affiliated with Black Lives Matter, but used as a reason why poltifact says that the money being donated through actblue doesn't get allocated directly to any political campaign. With the track record of the DNC i don't trust any of it.
 
In regards to Boogaloo:

I dont think it's ridiculous to question about the motives of a movement, even if it only seems to be lone actors so far.
A lone actor doesn't get his(almost always a dude) ideas in a vacuum; its usually part of a bigger ideology.
We know how groupthink works with people; what's starts as one can easily turn into others.

I do appreciate the answers y'all have given, even if it's not my viewpoint.

Florida173 said:
One grew out of a 4chan joke and is trying to bring about a second Civil War because of a bunch of disenfranchised "patriots" think they are doing the right thing (nothing conservative about that) and one is hyper socialist anti-capitalist group pretending to be against nazis. Antifa has nothing to do with liberalism.
Click to expand...

I wanted to highlight this in particular.
As much as ANTIFA may represent the worst of leftists and "disenfranchised Patriots" the worst of conservatives, I am of the same general mindset here of understanding that the fringe does not represent the majority.
 
Cookie_ said:
As much as ANTIFA may represent the worst of leftists and "disenfranchised Patriots" the worst of conservatives, I am of the same general mindset here of understanding that the fringe does not represent the majority
Click to expand...

I suggest stop thinking you can put these groups conveniently into your understanding of a two party political system. Antifa is actively trying to take down capitalism and the foundation of our republic. There's nothing democrat/republican about that.

The disenfranchised patriots is my phrase for the boog bois, and because it's come out of the gun culture/2a groups, you could probably find a high correlation with pro gun republican side, but again this stuff doesn't have to do with democrats and republicans. The republicans are just as much at fault for tearing down the bill of rights. You can look at the recent SCOTUS rulings to see that they are now retconning today's ideals into law. It's incredibly dangerous. Check out Levin's book Men in Black. So much truer today than when I read it like 15 years ago.
 
Florida173 said:
I suggest stop thinking you can put these groups conveniently into your understanding of a two party political system. Antifa is actively trying to take down capitalism and the foundation of our republic. There's nothing democrat/republican about that.

The disenfranchised patriots is my phrase for the boog bois, and because it's come out of the gun culture/2a groups, you could probably find a high correlation with pro gun republican side, but again this stuff doesn't have to do with democrats and republicans. The republicans are just as much at fault for tearing down the bill of rights. You can look at the recent SCOTUS rulings to see that they are now retconning today's ideals into law. It's incredibly dangerous. Check out Levin's book Men in Black. So much truer today than when I read it like 15 years ago.
Click to expand...

I think this an important point. Because we have two parties, we feel a need to sort people and groups into two buckets, not likely understanding that some of the "fringe" groups may not 'sort' quite so neatly. And part of the issue lies exactly in your language*: "....is my phrase...." Both the alt-right and the extreme left feel they are 'true patriots', and definitions are changed to suit one's subjective interpretation.

I do get a kick out of the name 'ANTIFA', who actually engages in fascist tactics...

*not knocking you at all, we all do this....
 

Similar threads

Board and Seize
Rationality and Erisology
2
Replies
29
Views
6K
Gunz
Gunz
Marauder06
Full Spectrum Ops in the Homeland- a "Vision for the Future?"
Replies
2
Views
2K
Red-Dot
Red-Dot
Ravage
SOF LEADER: A Salute to Special Operators, with Concern for Fraying of the Forces
Replies
0
Views
4K
Ravage
Ravage
Ravage
NIGHT STALKER LEAD: From the Air, Delivering, Protecting and Extracting SOF Warriors
Replies
0
Views
8K
Ravage
Ravage
B
Counterinsurgency Redux
Replies
4
Views
4K
CQB
CQB
Back
Top