Bread. Garlic bread, yeast bread, rolls, etc... covered in butter, garlic butter, honey butter, or others. Sometimes when I go to Outback I will order Caesar dressing on the side and dip my bread in that. Pretty much anytime I walk into a Publix I have to stay away from the bakery. However, their hotdog and hamburger buns (especially the french bread hamburger buns) are second to none and made fresh in the store.
Second would have to be pizza or bacon. That is a difficult tossup.