Observation -
If you play your character in Red Dead 2 like any of Clint's Spaghetti Western characters or Unforgiven, you have a good chance of finishing the game 'honorable.'.
It actually made the game more fun for me when it came to decisions, "what would Clint do?"
I went so far as to design my character's look and clothing to be similar to Eastwood's.
I played it like Ed Harris in Westworld and ended up with a VERY DISHONORABLE rating. I killed, robbed and pillaged my way through that game like a Nazi on meth. For my sins I got a bad flare up of carpal tunnel.